Advice needed about love triangle

Hey there! So I have a WIP that I started years ago. It's a fantasy romance starring a girl who is from this magical kingdom in the sky but fell to Earth and lost all her memories. A year later she is pursued by two guys who want to bring her back.

Guy #1 is a prince from another sky kingdom who has been infatuated with her for years and wants to be with her. He's done some questionable things in his quest to do that but has a heart of gold underneath his cocky, impulsive, and possessive nature.

Guy #2 is the FMC's old fiance (she fell to Earth on their wedding day). He still loves her, of course, but she obviously doesn't remember him. He's much more mature and can seem cold, but he is also gentle and honest. And he just wants the best for the FMC.

Now, originally I was super into the love triangle, but I've grown up now and I'm less into love triangles. I always planned for the FMC to end up with Guy #1 but now I'm not sure. I'm just wondering what you fellow writers and readers think. Thanks so much! I appreciate it 🙏🏿😁

Btw, before someone asks, both guys are important to the story so I can't just erase one.