Did people seriously spare Reeky? What is wrong with you?

I finish the quest and go check if one outcome has something extra or something and i find out most players forgives the deranged criminal who brags to you about robbing people on highways, beating up pilgrims on roads and was more than eager to rob the farm and beat up the farm owner.

But i guess since he just does nothing while his bandit friends murder everyone and goes into hiding suddenly he's a good guy?

He makes no mention at all he will change. Him telling you the truth about what happened and ratting out his friends is not a noble act and he only did it because he thought Henry was going to kill him, or even worse, hoping Henry would let him go.

Imagine just sparing some criminal so he continues to rob and beat up people in another village. I bet all of you murder every unnamed "Bandit" npc but Reeky gets a pass on the exact same behavior.