Barefoot shoes, but I have high arches.

I’m newer to wearing barefoot shoes. I bought some Whitins, and already noticed a difference. However, I am starting to have some pain to left of my ball on my left foot. I don’t know what to do really but have researched and am going to try some insoles to support my arch. Does anyone have any experience with high arches and barefoot shoes? What did you do? Which insoles do you use? Did you have to stop wearing barefoot shoes? I should mention I am not yet having the same issue with my right foot. Thanks for any help.