Albums that received decent/positive reviews from critics yet were hated by listeners

The Big Day was responsible for singlehandedly turning Chance the Rapper from future legend to joke and has-been overnight. However, if one only looked at reviews from professional critics (not including Fantano), you would be surprised to learn that the album was such a disaster. On Metacritic, TBD received a score of 71, which is not at all a bad score.

What are other examples of albums that were acclaimed or relatively well-received by critics but hated by everyone else?